-
Andrew R. Barnard
Rattle offers a new look at the Nutcracker, full of nostalgia and beautiful playing from those Berliners
Rattle has often been accused of fussiness, of letting the line drag to the point where the charm is lost. There’s few works that ask for as much charm as Tchaikovsky’s Nutcracker, which probably causes some justified apprehension on the part of those who are looking into this disc. I can see where the albums’ critics are coming from, simply because Rattle doesn’t succeed in matching the sprightly balletic qualities that other great conductors have been able to pull out of the work, particularly Dorati and Bychkov. Rattle offers wonderful big sound, phenomenal first desk playing (particularly from oboist Albrecht Mayer), and EMI’s sonics are top notch.But beyond these perhaps technical details, Rattle’s approach differs in many ways from the other versions I own, namely Gergiev/Kirov, Dorati/Concertgebouw, and Bychkov/Berlin, in addition to Bernstein/New York, Rostropovich/Berlin, and Lazarev/Bolshoi in the suite. Rattle takes more time than most, allowing him to uncover aspects of the score that often slip by in other conductor’s hands. As alluded to earlier, Rattle is less concerned with being balletic than probably all the aforementioned version, something which is most keenly felt in such numbers as the “Overture” and “March”. But even there, Rattle imparts a wistful nostalgia that holds one’s attention, although I still feel that he doesn’t match competition. It’s in the numbers that ask for more than amusement where Rattle really finds his place. After hearing his version of “The Waltz of the Snowflakes”, “The Arabian Dance”, “The Waltz of the Flowers”, and “Pas de Deux”, my other versions seem dull in comparison. Rattle finds an inner beauty in these numbers that is breathtaking. “Pas de Deux” eerily prophesies of what was to come in the “Pathetique”, making for a highly logical, yet unfamiliar perspective.When it’s all said and done, it’s the beauty of the Berliners’ tone that makes this disc extra special. Rattle uses his orchestra as a vehicle to display a vast palate of gorgeous colors, making for very festive music. Those wanting a Nutcracker to keep them on the go will meet certain disappointment, but for those who are willing to take the time, this new Rattle version is one of the best.
-
mary
What’s not to like
Great music, great conductor along with very good sound for the time frame. Highly recommended.
-
Fred
Beautifully recorded, buy this one.
The sound quality is excellent, Vivid and bright where it has to be, subdued where it should be subdued. Never distorted due to over modulation of the sound level for emphasis, a perfect Tchaikovsky NutcrackerThe conductor and his orchestra have rendered a gorgeous recording of this holiday classic, highly recommend buying this version.My previous favorite was the “Andre Previn, EMI Digital, Royal Philharmonic Orchestra,1986”, version.This version is now my favorite, simply for the purity of the sound quality,The seller, Belkin House in the United Kingdom, also delivered it safely to America from the United Kingdom in a well protected shipping envelope.
-
Linda W. Colson
Beautiful album!
This double vinyl album of the Nutcracker is so beautiful. The records are high quality and arrived in excellent condition. The quality of sound is wonderful, too, and the songs are so beautiful. So happy with my purchase.
-
Nelda
High Quality
This was a high-quality CD. The music was clear and as expected. It was wrapped in plastic and well-protected in the mailer. I would buy again from this business.
-
Angélica Ibáñez
Outstanding performance packed in a cereal box
Warner needs to step up their game with their line of LP records; no voucher code for a digital download (DG, DECCA, and the Berlin Philharmonic’s own label provide codes for digital downloads now), no inner booklet or gatefold outer sleeve. This was purchased for $25 in “Like new” condition from the Amazon Wherehouse and the price seems fair for what the set contains. However, at $35, this should be packaged in a sleeve that looks like it was made in a garage with a cereal box. Shame on you warner.In any case, the performance itself is wonderful! records were clean and reproduced no surface noise whatsoever.
-
Beverly C Redd
Beautiful music
Beautiful music to listen to.
-
Liang-Jang Chiang
Great sound and great music.
Enjoy it frequently during daytime and night .